‘Twinless’ Review: A Bold Dramedy Featuring Dylan O’Brien’s Best Performance Yet at Sundance 2025
Having witnessed James Sweeney’s debut film, Straight Up, at Outfest 2019, I was immediately struck by his unique comedic style and insightful exploration of sexuality. His latest work, Twinless, is another testament to his talent, weaving a narrative that is both creatively daring and emotionally resonant. With its premiere at Sundance 2025, this film promises to leave a lasting impression.
What Is ‘Twinless’ About?
Twinless opens with a striking scene set in a diner, quickly followed by the jarring sound of a car crash—events that become pivotal throughout the film. We learn that the crash has claimed the life of the charismatic Rocky, portrayed by Dylan O’Brien. His twin brother, Roman (also played by O’Brien), and their mother (Lauren Graham) are grappling with their loss, often isolating themselves and clashing in their grief. After a heated argument while sorting through Rocky’s belongings, Roman’s mother insists he seek help, leading him to a bereavement group specifically for those who have lost their twins.
The film establishes its dark comedic tone right from the start, with the group’s leader, played by Tasha Smith, delivering biting remarks about her own deceased sister. During a break, Roman connects with fellow group member Dennis (James Sweeney), and their awkward yet endearing bond blossoms as they engage in activities reminiscent of their lost twins’ lives, such as grocery shopping and playing Sims. This connection sets the stage for a series of unexpected twists that challenge our initial perceptions and deepen the narrative.
A Tonal Masterpiece
Twinless masterfully balances humor and heartbreak while occasionally venturing into darker territory. It evokes comparisons to Liz Feldman’s Dead to Me, as it navigates the complexities of grief and relationships, revealing the charming yet flawed nature of its characters. The film prompts viewers to ponder whether bad decisions equate to irredeemable character flaws, steering clear of simplistic answers.
Sweeney’s script is peppered with authentic humor that not only elicits laughter but also deepens our understanding of the characters. While one of Dennis’s traits feels somewhat exaggerated, the comedic timing remains consistently effective. The film is rich with poignant dialogue, capturing the raw emotions of loss. Lines like “Every day is a bad day now” and “I was a we — now I’m an I” resonate deeply, offering fresh perspectives on grief and loneliness.
The LGBTQ+ themes are seamlessly woven into the narrative, with the characters’ identities being integral yet not the sole focus of the story. Sweeney’s approach allows his queer characters to be depicted with a refreshing authenticity, portraying their flaws without resorting to stereotypes. The film addresses homophobia in a nuanced manner, enhancing the character arcs without trivializing their struggles.
Dylan O’Brien Shines in Dual Roles
Dylan O’Brien delivers a standout performance as Roman, showcasing remarkable depth and versatility. Roman, characterized as a well-meaning yet often misguided individual, is portrayed with a blend of strength and vulnerability that makes him relatable. O’Brien’s ability to embody both Roman and Rocky—albeit the latter through flashbacks—demonstrates his exceptional range, as he distinctly differentiates between the two characters through subtle physical nuances and mannerisms.
Supporting characters, like Dennis’s optimistic coworker Marcy (Aisling Franciosi), also defy initial expectations, evolving throughout the film in ways that captivate the audience. Though Graham’s character feels somewhat underdeveloped, the film’s other performances shine brightly, particularly Sweeney’s, who navigates a complex role with charisma and poise.
A Cinematic Achievement
Twinless is not only a compelling narrative filled with unexpected twists but also a visually engaging experience. Sweeney’s directorial choices, including a striking split-screen sequence, enhance the storytelling, drawing intriguing parallels between characters and themes.
This film stands out as a thought-provoking dramedy that invites audiences to grapple with its rich themes while enjoying a well-crafted story. With its blend of humor, heartache, and authenticity, Twinless establishes itself as a memorable cinematic experience, leaving viewers eager to see what Sweeney will create next.
